Now, what exactly IS yoga writing, you may ask. Since yoga is good for me, shouldn’t it be
good for my writing? Not so fast my
little holistically minded writer.
Yoga writing (my own term ;)) is writing in which the author has endeavored
so much to adhere to all of the writing rules, plus anything critique partners,
judges, random readers have said they must do to make their work “good”, that
they have created writing that is often extremely, if not completely, difficult
to read, not unlike this sentence which actually violates many rules, but is in
itself a twisted example of one form of yoga writing.
An easier to read example of yoga writing comes to mind from a few years
ago where an agent or editor mentioned he didn’t like the word “as”. There were cries and wailing women at this
pronouncement as writers fought to get all of the examples of the offending
word out of their work.
This led to some really odd yoga writing contortions, let me tell you. The
editor/agent (forgot which now) didn’t mean to attack the word itself, but
rather specific uses, or misuses, of the word. But many writers took it to their
hearts that the word must be destroyed, no matter how unwieldy it left some of
their sentences.
Another culprit, and more wide spread than the great “as” purge, is the
word “was”. Yes, this little dickens can
often be a sign of weak or lazy writing.
Many times a sentence with this monster in it can be turned into a
stronger, brighter, shiner, (and depending upon your genre) more able to leap
tall buildings in a single bound version of itself with a “was-ectomy” and some
reconstructive surgery.
But sometimes they need to be there for ease of reading, and well, because
removing them often leaves a weirdly twisted sentence that often takes longer
for the reader to read than it would have had there been a simple…was. Like the word “said” most readers don’t
notice “was”. Now, this isn’t carte blanch
to go dumping "was’s" all over the place.
But it does mean that you shouldn't panic and run screaming for the hills
if you have some legitimately in your work.
Our goal as writers is to make our work as evocative, inviting, and
magical as we can to a reader so we can pull them along the path of our story
with us. We can’t do that if we sprain
their brain with a confusing and tortured sentence structure.
Lol! I like your new name for this. It's so true, everyone keeps telling writer's what 'not' to write, or how to write, and if we're not careful, we forget to do that what we wanted to do - simply write.
ReplyDeleteThanks, T! It makes it easier to keep in mind I think ;).
DeleteWell put! Maybe we should all have signs over our keyboards, "Simply write."
Thanks for coming by and commenting!
Another informative blog post, Marie! Great job! :)
ReplyDeleteThanks, Cassi! And thanks for coming by!
DeleteMarie- stuck at work- can't get onto blogger :(
What a great expression - yoga writing. Yes, indeed. Tying yourself into editorial contortions because of some 'rule'. I agree completely. There. I just used an adverb. ;)
ReplyDeleteThanks, Greta :) You are such a rebel! LOL! Maybe we can start a trend, start writing, "Ummm, ya have some yaga writing going on here." on projects (both our own and friends ;)).
DeleteThanks for coming by and commenting!
I wrote much more happily before I was inundated by rules and preferences...once the first draft was finished I could go back and fix POV, passive voice, and anything else. Now I start hammering out a passage and doggonit if I don't stop to worry about whose POV I'm in or how many times I've used 'troubled heart' in the last three pages. Now I have a name for it, and I can tell it to go away until needed. THANKS
ReplyDeleteI agree! The innocence of not knowing what was "wrong" was a much better time to write. Maybe stick a "NO YOGA WRITING" on your computer?
DeleteHmmm- I may try that myself!
Thanks for coming by and commenting, Mona!
Hee! Great post Marie!!!
ReplyDeleteAnd you're right... Nothing in the English language is 100%... No rules! :)
Lisa
Thanks, Lisa! And thanks for coming by! Oooooo- maybe biker jackets that say "No Rules Writers" we could be a club! ;)
DeleteOh my yes! I found your link on the Insecure Writers Support Group page and was intrigued by your blog name. :)
ReplyDeleteI once fell victim to yoga writing - back when I first started. It got so twisted and convoluted I gave up and threw out the rules, starting fresh with a greater appreciation for moderation. :)
Nice to meet you!
Laura
Laura Eno
P.S. You might want to turn off your captcha before the first IWSG. Others in the group will mention it to you. ;)
Hi Laura! I'm so glad you came by (I'm looking forward to my first IWSG run next month!)
DeleteYou are so right, moderation is the key and something we all need to keep in mind.
Thank you for coming by and commenting! (and for the advice- I have no idea how to do that--but I'm on it! :))
Sorry I missed your blog when it first came out. I must have been consulting with my yogi, working on my latest pose, Dead Adverb Down. After I've learned this we are moving on to a head stand called Passive Voice Inverted. As I am currently doing a revision, all those shouldn'ts, don'ts and nevers are running rampant through the first draft daring me to get rid of ALL of them. It is so true that sometimes it's just much simpler to write sentences which speak to us whether they follow the rules or not. Great post.
ReplyDeleteSharon
LOL!!! I can just see you at your desk, contorting yourself ;).
DeleteThanks for coming by and commenting, Sharon! And don't let those nasty words taunt you into something twisted ;).